Elementary School Teacher Disciplines by Putting Students In "Box"
Posted:
var wn_last_ed_date = getLEDate("Jan 30, 2009 12:05 AM EST"); document.write(wn_last_ed_date);
Jan 29, 2009 10:05 PM MST
Featured Video
Child Placed in "Box" as PunishmentcoreAdsCreate('wnsz_20', 'loc', '100', 'wnsz_20', 'News');
Local News
Huntsville, AL- (WAAY) The parents of an autistic child say their daughter was forced to sit inside a box as a form of punishment.
Those parents contacted WAAY 31, saying they were outraged at how the teacher at Flat Rock Elementary School dealt with their special needs child.
They claim their child was forced into this wooden container that looks like a wardrobe box.
"She has put my child in an unsafe state," mother Penny Shrader said. "I won't allow it to happen to any other child or mine."
Shrader said her daughter's teacher put the 7-year-old in a box after she made a mess from eating ice cream.
Another parent told Shrader they'd seen the teacher put the girl in the box.
Since her daughter was subjected to the punishment, Shrader said the girl's asthma symptoms have worsened.
"This is what I'm trying to press to the school. It's not bad to discipline a normal kid in time out, it might be acceptable," Shrader said.
Jackson County School Superintendent Ken Harding said he confronted the teacher about the incident, and the teacher denied it. He said the teacher did admit to putting four other students in the box, but not Shrader's daughter.
He said the school board is looking into he incident, but feels the problem has been resolved since the box was taken out of the classroom.
Shrader says she's still not satisfied.
"To simply say you've taken and removed the box and talked to the teacher does not satisfy my child is safe when I'm an hour away trying to make money to raise her," she said. "It's just not acceptable."
Several federal, state and county agencies are investigating. The case is drawing national media attention.
Here is what some are saying about this story:
"Channel 31 News,I do not know the teacher, but as a special education teacher myself, I find it hard to believe that anyone who is dealing with the severity of some of these children on a day to day basis would be doing something harmful to them, or something that their parents would not know about.
In the picture you showed on the news this morning, it LOOKED like the "box" may actually have been a partition set in a way that the student's desk may have been enclosed against the wall or whiteboard with no top.
This would be similar to a voting booth or in school suspension desks where the student remains in the room with the teacher and class, but is isolated for a time for concentration purposes or behavior purposes. (Some children NEED a place with no distractions to calm down when they are upset.)
Although I have never had to use anything like this in my own teaching, (Georgia has special rooms with in school suspension supervisors where the children could be in a room with no other distractions besides that supervisor,) with the student's goals, behaviors, consequences, etc. laid out LEGALLY in an IEP (individualized education program,) which must be signed by the teacher, principal, and parent at least once a year, if behavior problems to that extent existed, they would be listed with a behavior modification plan attached.
Have you seen any of the IEPs from the students that were said to have been "put in a box" in that room? It would be my advice, for the journalists, as well as the parents involved, to look at their IEPs and see what behavior modifications they had agreed to have implemented. Special education teachers spend MUCH more time on paperwork and individualizing lessons for their children than regular education teachers are required to spend.
In addition to the time, they usually have much more out of pocket costs, but receive the same pay as regular education teachers. It is my opinion that this should have been researched more carefully and all of the facts been gathered before we threw this teacher under the bus.
-Angie-"**************************************************************************
"I live in the Flat Rock area with my two children. I am shocked that a person, a teacher, a SPECIAL EDUCATION TEACHER could be so vile as to place a child in a box as a form of punishment. This is children we are talking about, not animals.
However after watching your ten o'clock report, I am more appalled that our superintendent would say "the problem has been resolved by removing the box from the classroom". The problem will begin to resolve when this teacher and principle are both removed not only from this school, but from the education system entirely."
Chris"
****************************************************************************
"After watching your news report regarding a child placed in a box for punishment, I am concerned being a parent of a child that should be attending that particular school in the fall of 2009; Not gonna happen now! May be perhaps the teacher and the principal should go back and take more child psychology courses or research more ways to punish a child with special needs. A box?
I have heard of embarrassing a child to reprimand such behavior however treating the child as if it were a dog being house broken is uncalled for and could also be a huge safety factor including further liability for the school, are the administration of the school not concerned of fire safety or even storm safety?
What were they thinking? Maybe perhaps the principal should open their eyes, see what the teachers are doing in the classrooms. Further more as a parent visiting the classroom I would question why a box that size would be in the classroom any way.
Any one watching ABC's Super Nanny a time out is meant for the child to rethink the poor behavior, so what we want the child to suffocate because they were insubordinate to the teacher? Or is that box away for the teacher to get that child out of the way?
A teacher should have compassion, a strong desire for students to succeed, and be an open communicator with the parents; Maybe this teacher should rethink their career choice if putting a child in a box to reprimand poor behavior in the classroom is the only choice of reprimand a teacher of children of that age group or even the special need children could conjure.
Mrs. Shrader deserves to have answers for the treatment of her child, all of the parents whose children were placed in that ridiculous box should receive the same respect. An apology, a written plan of reprimand, actions taken other than the big box removed, what did the teacher do get a smaller box? It is too late now for the teacher to receive a slap on the wrist. Parents want to know how their children are reprimanded. There is no way this was printed in the handbook from the start of the school year.
I think this could be one of the most embarrassing moments for educators every where.
Seriously, a job truly well done!
I have known the superintendent for years, he is highly qualified; I am sure he was not aware of the reprimand obviously taking place in that particular classroom. I am rest assured he will take further action to resolve this issue and will be more proactive in reprimands taking place in Jackson County Schools.
Concerned and annoyed Parent from Flat Rock, Alabama"
*****************************************************************************
"I do not agree with any kind of abuse of a child while in the classroom. But if there were reason to discipline a student for any reason while they are within the walls of the school system, then action should be taken by the teachers.
If the parents of a child are not going to teach their children proper manners and respect of authority within or for that matter, outside of the home then they should not be offended when someone whom the child has been in trusted with takes action to correct bad behavior.
Parents should not automatically go up in arms when the professionals within our school system act to maintain control of kids who do not know how to behave while in public setting such as school.
It is a shame that parents are not instilling discipline to their children while at home and then are offended when someone such as a teacher has to take action to correct a child's misbehavior while in school.
Teachers are the administrators and children are the students. Kids are in school to learn. They should already know how to act before they step on the bus.
Keith, Decatur, Al."
**************************************************************************
"I have an autistic nephew and I am also a mother of an 11 year old little boy. I would be outraged if either my nephew or son were put in a "punishment box". Sounds like to me that teacher and principal need to spend some time in a dark box for a while to see how it feels!!!
My sister and brother-in-law work every day of their lives to get my nephew to the point he is right now!! A few minutes in a box like that would do so much damage and set him back terribly!! The teacher and principal should loose their jobs!!!!
If any parent put their kid in a box, they would be brought up on charges and DHR knocking on their door!!!! This makes me sick!!!!
Jennie, Ardmore, AL"
**************************************************************************"As the mother of a child that attends Flat Rock School I find this very disturbing. I am very disappointed in the Teacher and the Principle for allowing disciplinary actions such as putting a child in a box to take place in our school.
Actions such as this are an embarrassment to the community and to the school its self, none the less the damage done mentally to the child. Immediate actions need to take place to insure that an incident as this does not happin again.
School should be a safe learning enviroment that gives our children the best education possible and not a tourcher chamber that children are scared to attend.
Thanks, A Concerned Mother"
**************************************************************************
"I'm a concerned parent from the Flat Rock area. And I think this teacher should have been moved from first grade 3 years ago.
Because she does not have the nerves or the patient for 6 year olds. I had to go to her countless times for papers not graded right and other things that i will not mention.
From a caring parent. Tonya"
**************************************************************************
"We had to pull our daughter out of her class September 2007 also, she was being punished and had to eat her silent break in the "special spot" beside Mrs. Black, which turned out to be under the table on the floor.
Several parents were labeled as trouble makers by the school superintendent, and their voices were not even heard. Parents were no longer allowed to walk their children to class until after the "trouble makers" had recided and then it continued as before.
Calls were made to other local schools by the Principal discouraging them from excepting children from Flat Rock Elementary. Also, a PTO meeting was scheduled by the President, Jamie Timmons. and was canceled by the Principal because he didn't want a witch hunt.
The Principal has lied and covered up several incicents in the past concerning Mrs. Black, so instead of looking for a simple soultion, he has been found to be a big part of the problem. The parents of the children at Flat Rock Elementary would like to see him removed before he allows any more of these cover ups to arise.
Thank you. Rebecca"*************************************************************************
Reporter:
Haley BakerWritten by:
Brittany WoodbyWeb Producer-
Brett HaasCopyright 2009 WAAYTV.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
var WNG_JSKIT_COMMENTS_REGISTRATION_REQUIRED = 'True';
var WNG_JSKIT_RATINGS_REGISTRATION_REQUIRED = 'False';
var JSKit$Override = [["onDataLoad", wnShowHideJsKit]];
function wnGoToRegPage() {
var wnRegPageURL = '/global/link.asp?L=104054';
wnRegPageURL += '&function=manageprofile&mode=login&referrer=';
wnRegPageURL += escape('http://www.waaytv.com/global/story.asp?S=9758698');
window.location = wnRegPageURL;
}
#wnSocialToolsSection,
#wnSocialToolsSection td,
#wnSocialToolsSection textarea,
div#js-kit-body-element td,
div.js-SettingsWindow td {
font: 12px Verdana,Arial;
color: #000000;
}
#wnJsKitCommentingAll {
background: #FFFFFF url();
}
div.js-singleComment,
#wnJsKitCommentingLimited {
border-color: #CCCCCC;
}
div.js-kit-comments {
font: 12px Verdana,Arial;
color: #000000;
background: #FFFFFF url();
}
div.js-comment-stripe-1 {
font: 11px Verdana,Arial;
color: #000000;
background: #FFFFFF url();
}
div.js-comment-stripe-1 div.js-singleCommentINFO {
font: 11px Verdana,Arial;
color: #666666;
border-left-color: #666666;
}
div.js-comment-stripe-2 {
font: 11px Verdana,Arial;
color: #000000;
background: #F4F8FB url();
}
div.js-comment-stripe-2 div.js-singleCommentINFO {
font: 11px Verdana,Arial;
color: #666666;
border-left-color: #666666;
}
#wnJsKitCommentingLimited .terms {
font: 9px Verdana,Arial;
color: #666666;
}
Comments
Terms of Use: We welcome your participation in our community. Please keep your comments civil and on point. You must be at least 13 years of age to post comments. By submitting a comment, you agree to these
Terms of Service You must be logged in to leave a comment.
Login or registerLeave a comment@
Controls(
Powered by JS-Kit)
Page:
← 1 2 3 … 41 42 →Terry in Georgia
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
I live in the state of Georgia and we have no laws here governing restraint and/or seclusion in schools. A boy committed suicide in a seclusion room in a small town here in Georgia. For more information about restraint/seclusion read the national report done by National Disabilities Rights network at www.ndrn.org Their publication "School is Not supposed to Hurt" is an eye opener. CNN also did a national story on restraint and seclusion. just google, you'll find it.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 0 by 0)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
cyndi
Thursday, February 05, 2009
I have two autistic children and am outraged as everyone is. I don't care who the child is or what they have done. They do not deserve this kind of treatment.Everyone who was involved and knew this was going on should be held responsible. We trust these people to do whats best for our children when we are not with them. .Especially kids who can not tell you what goes on at school.Children with Autism have so much of a challenge already just to get through a day at school is a challenge most of the time.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 6 by 6 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Anonymous
Thursday, February 05, 2009
wrong punishment for a child.........Principal can't fire her though people...only the Supt. can recommend that and approve it.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 2 by 2 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Page:
← 1 2 3 … 41 42 →See all commentsClose windowElementary School Teacher Disciplines by Putting Stude...
Leave a comment@
Controls(
Powered by JS-Kit)
Page:
← 1 2 3 … 24 25 →Terry in Georgia
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
I live in the state of Georgia and we have no laws here governing restraint and/or seclusion in schools. A boy committed suicide in a seclusion room in a small town here in Georgia. For more information about restraint/seclusion read the national report done by National Disabilities Rights network at www.ndrn.org Their publication "School is Not supposed to Hurt" is an eye opener. CNN also did a national story on restraint and seclusion. just google, you'll find it.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 0 by 0)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
cyndi
Thursday, February 05, 2009
I have two autistic children and am outraged as everyone is. I don't care who the child is or what they have done. They do not deserve this kind of treatment.Everyone who was involved and knew this was going on should be held responsible. We trust these people to do whats best for our children when we are not with them. .Especially kids who can not tell you what goes on at school.Children with Autism have so much of a challenge already just to get through a day at school is a challenge most of the time.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 6 by 6 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Anonymous
Thursday, February 05, 2009
wrong punishment for a child.........Principal can't fire her though people...only the Supt. can recommend that and approve it.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 2 by 2 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Anonymous
Thursday, February 05, 2009
The pressure should be mounting by the day from the parents, community, DHR, and state officials to get to the bottom of this. I agree that the teacher and the principal should not be allowed to work with our precious youth. Please, concerned adults, take this and any other opportunity you may have to sound off in support of the children. The School Board and Superintendent may hear us, they should. Remove these two adults from the education scene. Hire people who want to help children, not put them in danger.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 4 by 4 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Anonymous
Thursday, February 05, 2009
Jackson County Board of Ed. meeting next Thursday, February 12, 2009.
Like this comment? [] [] (Score: 0 by 2 votes)
Community assigned karma score: 0 by 0
Mark as
[] [] [] []
Page:
← 1 2 3 … 24 25 →Close window